WWW.JESUSRADICALS.COM
  • About
  • Rock! Paper! Scissors!
    • What's in a Name?
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Call for Content
    • Past Issues >
      • Blog Archives (2005 - 2017)
      • Liberation for Every Body
      • The Movement Makes Us Human
      • Truth, Trust, and Power
      • Art Against Empire
      • Earth, Ecology, and the End of the Age
      • Decolonization, Incarnation, and Liberation
  • Library
    • Add an entry
    • Letter A >
      • Abelism
      • Accountability
      • Ally
      • Anarchism
      • Animal Liberation
      • Anthropocentrism
      • Assimilation
    • Letter B >
      • Base Communities
      • Biblical Exegisis
    • Letter C >
      • Capitalism
      • Catholic Worker
      • Civilization
    • Letter D >
      • Decolonization
      • Direct Action
    • Letter F >
      • Factory Farming
      • Feminism
      • Foraging
    • Letter G >
      • Genocide
      • Globalization
    • Letter H >
      • Heteropatriarchy
      • Humane Killing
    • Letter I >
      • Internalized Oppression
      • Intersectionality
    • Letter L >
      • Liberation Theology
    • Letter M >
      • Marginal Voices
      • Mass Media
    • Letter N >
      • Nonviolence
    • Letter O >
      • Othering
    • Letter P >
      • Pedagogies of Liberation
      • Police
      • Privilege
    • Letter Q >
      • Queer
    • Letter R >
      • Racism
      • Resurrection
    • Letter S >
      • Speceisism
      • Spiritual/Cultural Appropriation
      • State
    • Letter T >
      • Technology
      • Theopolitics
    • Letter V >
      • Voting
    • Letter W >
      • War
      • White Supremacy
  • Iconocast
    • Collective
    • Canvas
  • Donate
  • Contact
  • Join Us
  • About
  • Rock! Paper! Scissors!
    • What's in a Name?
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Call for Content
    • Past Issues >
      • Blog Archives (2005 - 2017)
      • Liberation for Every Body
      • The Movement Makes Us Human
      • Truth, Trust, and Power
      • Art Against Empire
      • Earth, Ecology, and the End of the Age
      • Decolonization, Incarnation, and Liberation
  • Library
    • Add an entry
    • Letter A >
      • Abelism
      • Accountability
      • Ally
      • Anarchism
      • Animal Liberation
      • Anthropocentrism
      • Assimilation
    • Letter B >
      • Base Communities
      • Biblical Exegisis
    • Letter C >
      • Capitalism
      • Catholic Worker
      • Civilization
    • Letter D >
      • Decolonization
      • Direct Action
    • Letter F >
      • Factory Farming
      • Feminism
      • Foraging
    • Letter G >
      • Genocide
      • Globalization
    • Letter H >
      • Heteropatriarchy
      • Humane Killing
    • Letter I >
      • Internalized Oppression
      • Intersectionality
    • Letter L >
      • Liberation Theology
    • Letter M >
      • Marginal Voices
      • Mass Media
    • Letter N >
      • Nonviolence
    • Letter O >
      • Othering
    • Letter P >
      • Pedagogies of Liberation
      • Police
      • Privilege
    • Letter Q >
      • Queer
    • Letter R >
      • Racism
      • Resurrection
    • Letter S >
      • Speceisism
      • Spiritual/Cultural Appropriation
      • State
    • Letter T >
      • Technology
      • Theopolitics
    • Letter V >
      • Voting
    • Letter W >
      • War
      • White Supremacy
  • Iconocast
    • Collective
    • Canvas
  • Donate
  • Contact
  • Join Us
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

  Archives

      Jesus Radicals Blog 2005-2017

4/2/2015 Comments

On Blackness and Value: Whiteness as Credit

By: Amaryah Armstrong
Part 1, Part 3
Note: This article was originally posted on Women in Theology  and is the second in a three part series.
Picture
“The credit economy is a network of contracted servitude. … Whenever one spends money, one spends a portion of the substance, wealth and life of those who have undertaken loans. Yet the value of money is also backed by profitability, including the drudge of labour in sweatshops and factories, the exclusion from the formal economy of those who are not employed profitably, the consumption of natural resources and the erosion of ecosystems and societies. The value of money is still paid for in flesh and blood.” (Philip Goodchild, Theology of Money, 239)

“The debtor may be infinitely removed from equality with her debt, she may have infinitely little in common with what she owes, but this gap between her privative actuality and the telos that is promised her on credit still renders her visible as a figure of this economy.” (Sean Capener, An Unbloody Priesthood in an Economy of Blood)

“Although the existence of certain property rights may seem self-evident, and the protection of certain expectations may seem essential for social stability, property is a legal construct by which selected private interests are protected and upheld. In creating property ‘rights,’ the law draws boundaries and enforces or reorders existing regimes of power. The inequalities that are produced and reproduced are not givens or inevitabilities; rather, they are conscious selections regarding the structuring of social relations. In this sense, it is contended that property rights and interests are not ‘natural’ but ‘creation[s] of law.’ In a society structured on racial subordination, white privilege became an expectation and … whiteness became the quintessential property for personhood.” (Cheryl Harris, Whiteness as Property, 280-81)

In the first post of this series, I put forth Philip Goodchild’s idea that we must think ecologically about money – think about the social relations it produces and enables. I furthered this thought by suggesting we must also think about money itself ecologically – about the relations that enable the invention and maintenance of money. Understanding the invention of capital as occurring through racialization is crucial to this ecological thought.

As noted in the previous post, Denise Ferreira Da Silva and Paula Chakravartty understand blackness and brownness as demarcations of exclusion from a set of social relations. Goodchild notes too that poverty is this threat of exclusion from the normative economic set of social relations. We can understand racialization, then, as the process of delimiting the poor from the rich. This threat of poverty and the figuration of poverty through the indelible indebtedness of racialization as black or brown is what gives money’s promise of value meaning. Here I want to examine what is deemed valuable as a way of understanding how criminality functions. For there to be a criminal requires the understanding of what is not criminal and why it is not. As I posit the criminalization of blackness as an effect of the relations between blackness and value, I also present whiteness and the benefits and privileges accrued to whiteness as structured by a relation to value. That relation is one of credibility – of being credible.

What it means to be white is to be included within relations that traffic in credibility. Being credible is not the same thing as not having debt. As Capener notes above, being credible is the separation of one’s debt from one’s self. One is not one’s debt even if one is a debtor. Thus, one is still recognizable as a figure within the capitalist economy because one’s debt never dissolves one’s self. Whiteness is the assurance of the fact that one is a subject, agent, and owner of one’s self. This is, as Cheryl Harris notes in the quote above, the value of whiteness as a property of one’s self. Further, as a property of one’s self that is valuable because of its credibility, the expectation for how one is to be recognized and related to is as one who is credible – as one whose place as a subject who is able to exchange objects always ought to be recognized.

Yet this expectation of recognition as credible requires a misrecognition or disappearance of what makes this recognition possible. Goodchild notes this by pointing to what it means to be credible – to participate in an economy structured on credit and debt. There is a whole structure of servitude operating. Some flesh and blood is being used to pay for the credit of others. Some flesh and blood are permanently indebted so that whiteness can be recognizable as a credible subjectivity. The property of being white is the demarcation of who is the owner of property rather than being owned by property.

We can see these relationships between race and credit/debt, property and ownership, at work in the case of Darren Wilson’s murder of Mike Brown. In the aftermath of the murder, the global protests and marches of solidarity, the refusal of the state to indict Wilson, and the growing resentment on display by many white people tired of black people ‘making this about race,’ what becomes clear is the expectation of credibility in contradistinction to the expectation of indebtedness.

For example, part of the failure to indict Darren Wilson by the grand jury had to do with issues of credibility. Who is a credible witness? Who is a credible subject? In this case, the recounting of events by black people have been roundly dismissed as not credible precisely because of their blackness, which is the propensity to “make things about race” and lie about the violence of history as it happened. Meanwhile, the anonymous white woman, Witness 40, whose legitimacy as a witness was challenged by the FBI (and it’s increasingly becoming clear she may not have even been present at the scene of the murder) is still legible as a credible witness in the logic of whiteness. Sean Hannity and others continue repeating her affirmation of Darren Wilson’s account of Mike Brown “charging” him. Additionally, Wilson’s own account, is considered especially credible. Not only because he is white, but because as a police officer he protects and enforces credibility, which is to the interest of private property. Despite his exceptional disregard for the actually legally stated procedures with which police are to respond to ‘criminals’ or handle evidence or file reports, Wilson is treated as a hero by many whites, has been given a national interview in which he expresses no remorse for killing Brown, and has had over half a million dollars donated to him. In short, it pays to be credible, to be white, precisely because it is black flesh and blood that pays rather than one’s self.

Indeed, in many white responses to Ferguson, there is lividness at the idea of anyone thinking an injustice has occurred. Any support of Brown, his family, the Ferguson protestors, etc, is met with incredulity based on the assumption that black people are indebted in some way to white people. Whether for being in America and having access to it’s wealth of economic opportunities, for being freed from slavery, for the ways white people have tried to ‘help’ black people—there is the latent idea that white people are owed a certain behavior from black people which is not consistent with the performance of protest. In this example we can see black people’s indebtedness is understood as one with their being,. Black poverty and experiences of policing are black people’s own fault. If blacks would simply become credible subjects, as white people are, they would not be such moral failures, they would not be so poor, they would not be so violent – so criminal.

In short, blackness is not recognizable apart from the imposition of a permanent indebtedness. On the other hand, whiteness is only recognizable as being separate from its debts, even when history, the law, and one’s own behavior raises questions about the justness with which this credibility is extended, circulated, and maintained.

Picture
Amaryah Armstrong is a PhD student in theological studies and philosophy of religion. currently exploring the relationship between political theology, race, and property. She also blogs at Women in Theology and is on Twitter as @amaryah_ja.

Comments
comments powered by Disqus

    RSS Feed

    Disclaimer
    The viewpoints expressed in each reader-submitted article are the authors own, and not an “official Jesus Radicals” position. For more on our editorial policies, visit our submissions page. If you want to contact an author or you have questions, suggestions, or concerns, please contact us.

    Categories

    All Accountability Advent Anarchism Animal Liberation Anthropocentrism Appropriation Biblical Exegesis Book Reviews Bread Capitalism Catholic Worker Christmas Civilization Community Complicity Confessing Cultural Hegemony Decolonization Direct Action Easter Economics Feminism Heteropatriarchy Immigration Imperialism Intersectionality Jesus Justice Lent Liberation Theology Love Mutual Liberation Nation-state Nonviolence Occupy Othering Pacifisim Peace Pedagogies Of Liberation Police Privilege Property Queer Racism Resistance Resurrection Sexuality Solidarity Speciesism Spiritual Practices Technology Temptation Veganism Violence War What We're Reading On . . . White Supremacy Zionism


    Contributors

    Nekeisha  Alayna Alexis
    Amaryah Armstrong
    Autumn Brown
    HH Brownsmith
    Jarrod Cochran 

    Chelsea Collonge
    Keith Hebden
    Ric Hudgens

    Liza Minno Bloom
    Jocelyn Perry
    Eda Ruhiye Uca
    Joanna Shenk

    Nichola Torbett
    Mark VanSteenwyk
    Gregory Williams

    Archives

    October 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    November 2013
    July 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    June 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    November 2009
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009
    October 2008
    August 2008

Home  |  About  |  Blog  |  Iconocast  |  Library  |  Gatherings  |  Donate  |  Contact  |  Comrades